Citizenship Bill gets LS nod amid protests in Northeast
The Lok Sabha on Tuesday passed a contentious Bill seeking to provide Indian citizenship to non-Muslims from Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan, amid protests in Northeastern states and opposition parties terming the proposed law “divisive” and “flawed”.
Immediately after Home Minister Rajnath Singh introduced the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill 2019, Senior Congress leader Mallikarjun Kharge said there are “flaws” in the Bill that does not address the Assam Accord and requested the Speaker to send it to a select committee. His party walked out after the Speaker refused to accept the demand.
Other opposition party leaders, including TMC’s Saugata Roy dubbed the bill as “divisive” and “insidious” that goes against the basic tenets of the Constitution. “This is the worst form of vote-bank politics”, Roy added.
Defending the Bill, which he said was not “Assam-centric”, the Home Minister asserted that the Bill was not against the provisions of the
Constitution and would give succour to persecuted minorities in three neighbouring countries, as they “have no place to go to, except India.”
Rejecting the contention that the Bill sought to discriminate people on the basis of religion, Singh said, “Anyone eligible under the provisions under the law will be accorded citizenship”.
The new Bill has become more contentious in the wake of allegations that the draft National Register of Citizens (NRC), being implemented in Assam, leaves out lakhs of people which allegedly include mostly Muslims immigrants. Opponents have alleged that the new Bill legitimises non-Muslim immigrants, while Muslims who might have had migrated years ago to India would be deported post-NRC.
Seeking to assuage the concerns in the Northeast, which saw an 11-hour bandh on Tuesday against the legislation, Singh said the proposed law will not be confined to Assam alone. “The burden of those persecuted migrants will be shared by the whole country. Assam alone should not have to bear the entire burden. Government of India is committed to give all help to the state government and people of Assam,” he said.
The Bill provides for according Indian citizenship to Hindus, Jains, Christians, Sikhs, Buddhists and Parsis from Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan after six years of residence in India instead of 12 years, which is the norm currently, even if they do not possess any document.
There has been a strong opposition in Assam and other Northeastern states against the Bill, especially after Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s address in Silichar last Friday when he said, “The Citizenship Bill is an atonement of the wrong that was done during India’s Partition… India will safeguard all who had been victims of the Partition.”
Political parties, student groups and others have been protesting on the grounds that the Bill seeks to grant nationality to non-Muslims, who have come up to December 31, 2014, thereby, increasing the deadline from 1971 as per the Assam accord. Also as per the accord, all illegal immigrants, irrespective of religion, have to be deported and this Bill violates that, Asom Gana Parishad said while quitting the alliance with the BJP in Assam on Monday.
During the nearly three-hour debate, the Home Minister said the Union cabinet has also approved grant of ST status to six communities of Assam namely Tai Ahom, Koch Rajbongshi, Chutia, Tea Tribes, Moran and Matak. However, an official release from the Home Ministry clarified that the government has “waived the requirement of cabinet approval” for the Bill granting ST status to these six communities. The government’s decision is being seen as a balancing act by the Centre in a bid to assuage concerns in Assam.
Agitators clashed with police, gheraoed Chief Minister Sarbananda Sonowal’s house at his native place in Dibrugarh, blocked national highways and damaged vehicles in Assam during the ‘bandh’. The AASU activists tried to ransack a BJP office in Dibrugarh, prompting police to resort to lathi charge and fire rubber bullets. Protests were also held in other Northeastern states and in West Bengal.
Apart from NDA allies, Shiv Sena and JD (U), Mizoram and Meghalaya governments have also opposed the bill.